advanced33 min studyLesson 517 in Mathematics

Tensor products and dual representations

Combine symmetry actions, track inverse-transpose duals, and separate symmetric from alternating tensor sectors.

On this page

What you’ll understand

  • Derive the tensor and dual character formulas.
  • Decompose a tensor product using character inner products.
  • Distinguish the dual matrix from the adjoint and compute symmetric and alternating squares.

Combining two systems often means taking a tensor product of their state spaces, with each symmetry acting on both factors at once. Linear observables live in dual spaces, where inverse action is required to preserve evaluation. These constructions have simple character rules even when their matrices become large. They also make conjugation conventions unavoidable: a dual action is inverse transpose, while its character becomes complex conjugate only after the finite-group complex hypotheses are used.

Tensor products multiply traces

For representations on V and W, define the group action on a pure tensor by applying the group element to both factors, then extend linearly. The group multiplication law holds because it holds separately in each factor. A basis of tensor products has one vector per ordered pair of basis vectors, so dimensions multiply. The trace of a tensor-product matrix is the product of the traces, giving a pointwise product formula for characters. The resulting representation need not be irreducible even when both factors are.

To decompose a tensor product, multiply character values class by class and take weighted inner products with the irreducible table. This method avoids constructing a matrix of size equal to the product of dimensions for every group element. It identifies how many copies occur, though not a preferred basis in each copy. Such decompositions organize possible symmetry types of products, bilinear operations, and coupled degrees of freedom. They are exact finite-dimensional statements here, without approximation or a probabilistic independence assumption.

ρV⊗W(g)=ρV(g)⊗ρW(g),χV⊗W(g)=χV(g)χW(g),mU=⟨χVχW,χU⟩\rho_{V\otimes W}(g)=\rho_V(g)\otimes\rho_W(g),\qquad \chi_{V\otimes W}(g)=\chi_V(g)\chi_W(g),\qquad m_U=\langle\chi_V\chi_W,\chi_U\rangle
The character product is pointwise, not the convolution introduced in the Fourier lesson. Dimensions multiply at the identity.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

Duals preserve evaluation

A dual vector is a linear functional. Define the action on a functional by precomposing with the inverse group action, so evaluating a transformed functional on a transformed vector returns the original scalar. In dual bases the matrix is the transpose of the inverse, not generally the conjugate transpose. Its trace is the original character at the inverse group element. Since finite-order complex eigenvalues lie on the unit circle, this equals the complex conjugate of the original character.

After choosing an invariant Hermitian form and orthonormal coordinates, the original matrices are unitary. Then the inverse transpose equals the entrywise complex conjugate matrix. It still need not equal the adjoint matrix, which is instead the inverse. This difference is visible in dimension greater than one whenever a unitary matrix is not symmetric. The conjugate representation and the dual representation are equivalent in this unitary setting, but that equivalence should not be confused with a basis-independent identity between their underlying spaces.

ρV∗(g)=ρV(g−1)T,χV∗(g)=χV(g)‾,ρV(g) unitary⟹ρV∗(g)=ρV(g)‾\rho_{V^*}(g)=\rho_V(g^{-1})^{\mathsf T},\qquad \chi_{V^*}(g)=\overline{\chi_V(g)},\qquad \rho_V(g)\text{ unitary}\Longrightarrow\rho_{V^*}(g)=\overline{\rho_V(g)}
Transpose expresses the algebraic dual. Entrywise conjugation appears in unitary coordinates; adjoint and dual are different matrix operations.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

Symmetric and alternating sectors

The tensor square has an operator that swaps its two factors. This swap commutes with the group action, so its positive and negative eigenspaces are invariant. Over the complex numbers, dividing identity plus or minus swap by two gives the corresponding projections. Their images are the symmetric and alternating squares, with dimensions respectively d(d+1)/2d(d+1)/2 and d(d−1)/2d(d-1)/2. A swap eigenvalue concerns the two factors, not the sign of a group permutation acting on the original space.

If the eigenvalues of a group element on V are listed, the symmetric square contains their pairwise products with repeated indices allowed, while the alternating square uses distinct unordered pairs. Expanding the square of their sum separates these two lists. The correction term is the sum of the squared eigenvalues, which is the character at the square of the group element. This derives the familiar half-sum and half-difference formulas rather than guessing them from dimensions at the identity.

Square the standard S3 representation

Let U have character (2,0,−1)(2,0,-1) on the identity, transposition, and three-cycle classes of S3S_3. Decompose its tensor square and identify its symmetric and alternating parts.

  1. The tensor-square character is (4,0,1)(4,0,1). Inner products with trivial, sign, and standard give respectively (4+2)/6=1(4+2)/6=1, (4+2)/6=1(4+2)/6=1, and (8−2)/6=1(8-2)/6=1.

  2. The square-element character values are (2,2,−1)(2,2,-1). Therefore χSym⁡2U=(χU2+χU(g2))/2=(3,1,0)\chi_{\operatorname{Sym}^2U}=(\chi_U^2+\chi_U(g^2))/2=(3,1,0), whereas χ⋀2U=(1,−1,1)\chi_{\bigwedge^2U}=(1,-1,1).

  3. Thus U⊗U≅1⊕ε⊕UU\otimes U\cong\mathbf1\oplus\varepsilon\oplus U, with Sym⁡2U≅1⊕U\operatorname{Sym}^2U\cong\mathbf1\oplus U and ⋀2U≅ε\bigwedge^2U\cong\varepsilon. The dimensions are 4=3+1=1+1+24=3+1=1+1+2, so every sector is accounted for.

The result

The alternating square is the determinant, hence sign, representation. The symmetric square contains the invariant quadratic form and a standard two-dimensional component.

Explore the model

Interactive lab

Interactive lab · waves

Addition of phases is not addition of characters

Pause and Reset, then set both phase 120120 degrees and amplitude ratio 11, predicting resultant amplitude 11. Reset and set both phase −120-120 degrees and ratio 11, predicting the same amplitude with conjugated phase data. The lab adds two wave amplitudes; it illustrates complex conjugate phases but does not multiply character values or form a tensor product. Compute the product ωω2=1\omega\omega^2=1 separately to contrast tensor multiplication with the displayed sum. Controls retain time unless Reset is used.

Addition of phases is not addition of charactersTwo waves share the same frequency and wave number. Playback advances t in sin(2x − t) + a sin(2x − t + phase). Current readings: Sum at x = 0: 0.866; Resultant amplitude: 1.732; Phase difference: 60°. All parameters are adjustable with the labeled controls below.−3.14−1.5701.573.14−3.4−1.701.73.4x · radiansAmplitude
SumFirst componentSecond component
Sum at x = 0
0.866
Resultant amplitude
1.732
Phase difference
60°
t = 0 s

Two waves share the same frequency and wave number. Playback advances t in sin(2x − t) + a sin(2x − t + phase). Parameter changes pause playback and recompute the model at the current elapsed time. Reset restores both parameters and returns time to zero. Playback starts paused. Adjust either parameter, then choose Play or Step.

Look forTensor characters multiply, direct-sum characters add, and dual characters conjugate; these operations must remain distinct.

Check your understanding

In dual bases, what is the correct matrix for the algebraic dual representation?

Try it yourself

For C3C_3, write W=χ1⊕χ2W=\chi_1\oplus\chi_2, with χk(r)=ωk\chi_k(r)=\omega^k. Find W∗W^* and decompose W⊗WW\otimes W. Identify the number of invariant vectors in the tensor square.

Take a moment to make a prediction or work it out on paper. Open a hint when you need one.

Give me a hint

The dual negates the exponent modulo three. Expand the tensor square by distributing over the two direct sums.

Compare with the solution

Duality exchanges χ1\chi_1 and χ2\chi_2, so W∗≅WW^*\cong W. The four tensor terms have exponents 2,0,0,12,0,0,1 modulo three, giving W⊗W≅χ2⊕1⊕2⊕χ1W\otimes W\cong\chi_2\oplus\mathbf1^{\oplus2}\oplus\chi_1. Its invariant subspace is therefore two dimensional. All four summands have dimension one, matching the tensor-space dimension four; the two invariant terms arise from the two ordered mixed factors.

Take it with you

  • Tensor products multiply characters but need not preserve irreducibility.
  • Dual matrices are inverse transpose; finite complex characters become conjugate.
  • Factor-swap projections separate symmetric and alternating invariant sectors.

Read further

Original sources and deeper explanations to follow at your own pace.

Optional progress, saved in this browser when available. Revisit any lesson at any time.

Lesson not marked complete.