research35 min studyLesson 778 in Physics

Topological defects and fusion rules

Describe how topological defects compose, distinguish direct-sum multiplicities from probabilities, and identify what a fusion ring leaves unspecified.

On this page

What you’ll understand

  • Use support codimension and deformation rules to define a topological symmetry defect.
  • Calculate group-like fusion and a reducible noninvertible sum.
  • Separate fusion coefficients, quantum dimensions, junction data, and Hilbert-space operators.

A topological defect can be moved without changing a correlator as long as it crosses no charged insertion or specified junction. Bringing parallel defects together defines fusion. For invertible symmetry defects this reproduces a group, but more general fusion can yield a direct sum of sectors. The coefficients in that sum count channels, rather than classical probabilities. We use topological lines in two spacetime dimensions to make the algebra concrete while keeping fusion objects distinct from arbitrary matrices on a chosen state space.

Fusion is a local composition of extended operators

In D equal to two, a line has codimension one and can implement an ordinary zero-form symmetry. Its topological property permits shrinking a thin strip between two parallel lines into a fused line, subject to their junction data. A group-like line has an oppositely oriented inverse whose fusion gives only the identity line. Topological lines can occur inside a gapless conformal theory; their existence does not require the whole bulk theory to be metric independent.

For a finite set of simple defects, record nonnegative integer multiplicities for their fusion outcomes. A simple line cannot itself be decomposed as a direct sum of smaller allowed lines. Associativity constrains the multiplicities, but different ways of joining and reassociating lines can involve nontrivial linear maps on junction spaces. Knowing only the multiplication table therefore does not reconstruct the full fusion category or its anomalies.

Da×Db=⨁cNab  cDc,Nab  c∈Z≥0,Da×I=DaD_a\times D_b=\bigoplus_cN_{ab}^{\ \ c}D_c,\qquad N_{ab}^{\ \ c}\in\mathbb Z_{\ge0},\qquad D_a\times I=D_a
The supports are topological lines in D = 2 spacetime, representing zero-form defect operators. N counts independent fusion channels, not normalized outcome probabilities. The direct-sum symbol records sector decomposition; associator and junction data are additional.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

A sum of group defects need not be invertible

Consider the three invertible lines of an anomaly-free Z₃ symmetry, generated by g with its cube equal to the identity. Their fusion is addition modulo three. Now form the reducible direct sum of all three lines. Multiplying this sum by itself produces every group element three times, because for each target label there are three ordered pairs of summands. The resulting object is not a new group element with a group inverse.

In any Hilbert-space representation of this ordinary unitary group action, dividing the corresponding summed operator by three gives a projector onto invariant states. The division is an operator normalization, not a physical direct sum with fractional sector multiplicities. A projection can have a kernel even in a perfectly unitary theory because it is not time evolution. This elementary reducible example prepares the algebraic idea of noninvertibility without claiming that every projection defines a new simple symmetry defect.

g3=I,A=I⊕g⊕g2,A×A=3A,P=I+Ug+Ug23,P2=Pg^3=I,\qquad A=I\oplus g\oplus g^2,\qquad A\times A=3A,\qquad P=\frac{I+U_g+U_g^2}{3},\quad P^2=P
A is a reducible defect object; P is a normalized operator in a group representation with Ug³ = I. The coefficient three is a multiplicity. P need not be an invertible or simple topological line, and its rank depends on the representation.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

Quantum dimensions are positive fusion characters

For a unitary finite fusion setting, positive quantum dimensions multiply under fusion and add under direct sum. Every invertible simple group defect has dimension one, while the reducible sum above has dimension three. A noninteger quantum dimension can appear for a genuinely simple noninvertible line, but that value alone does not specify the action on every state or the complete junction theory. Quantum dimension is not ordinary spatial dimension or the number of local field components.

The same fusion ring can admit different associator data, so a numerical multiplication check is necessary but incomplete. Physical questions also depend on which defects exist in the chosen theory, how they end on boundaries, and how they pass local or extended operators. A toy representation can test an exact algebraic consequence, but it cannot establish a microscopic symmetry, a protected phase, or a categorical anomaly from its matrix entries alone.

dadb=∑cNab  cdc,dI=1,dg=1,dA=3d_ad_b=\sum_cN_{ab}^{\ \ c}d_c,\qquad d_I=1,\qquad d_g=1,\quad d_A=3
The positive numbers d are quantum dimensions in the stated unitary fusion setting. They are dimensionless and additive on direct sums. This fusion-character identity omits associator phases and does not turn a reducible sum into a simple defect.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

Fuse a reducible Z₃ sum

Use g³ = I and A = I ⊕ g ⊕ g². Expand A², find its quantum dimension, and verify that P = (I + Ug + Ug²)/3 is a projector in a unitary group representation.

  1. The nine ordered products contain I, g, and g² three times each, so A2=3AA^2=3A.

  2. Additivity gives dA = 1 + 1 + 1 = 3. Multiplication checks dA2=9=3dAd_A^2=9=3d_A.

  3. The represented numerator squares to three times itself. Dividing by nine gives P2=PP^2=P. This checks a projection, not a unitary inverse for A.

The result

A² = 3A, dA = 3, and the normalized represented sum is a projector onto the invariant subspace.

Explore the model

Interactive lab

Interactive lab · modular

Group-like fusion returns to the identity

Reset and set BOTH Modulus m to 4 and Additive step a to 1; predict period 4. Then Reset and set BOTH m to 4 and a to 2; predict period 2. These exact cyclic orbits illustrate orders of invertible labels. The instrument has no direct-sum fusion, multiplicity spaces, associator, quantum dimension, or projection on a physical Hilbert space.

Group-like fusion returns to the identityAddition modulo m starts at zero: rₙ = na mod m. Playback advances two additions per second. The orbit has period m/gcd(m,a), including period one for a = 0. This is not a cryptographic security test or a primality algorithm. Current readings: Residue r0: 0; Orbit period · m/gcd(m,a): 12; Distinct residues visited: 1 of 12. All parameters are adjustable with the labeled controls below.Repeated addition modulo 12: the current residue is 0, and the orbit period is 12.01234567891011+ 5mod 12An additive orbitn = 0rₙ = 0Period = 12Cycle starts at 0:0 → 5 → 10 → 3 →8 → 1 → 6 → 11 →4 → 9 → 2 → 7 → 0Exact residues · two additions per second
Additive orbitCurrent residue / next edge
Residue r0
0
Orbit period · m/gcd(m,a)
12
Distinct residues visited
1 of 12
t = 0 s

Addition modulo m starts at zero: rₙ = na mod m. Playback advances two additions per second. The orbit has period m/gcd(m,a), including period one for a = 0. This is not a cryptographic security test or a primality algorithm. Parameter changes pause playback and recompute the model at the current elapsed time. Reset restores both parameters and returns time to zero. Playback starts paused. Adjust either parameter, then choose Play or Step.

Look forA cyclic group law is an exact example of fusion, but general defects carry more data than one orbit.

Check your understanding

What does a coefficient Nₐᵦᶜ = 2 in a fusion rule mean?

Try it yourself

For an anomaly-free Z₄ group-like defect g, define h = g² and B = I ⊕ h. Find B², B³, and dB. Is B a simple invertible defect?

Take a moment to make a prediction or work it out on paper. Open a hint when you need one.

Give me a hint

Use h² = I, distribute the direct sums, and distinguish an object sum from a group element.

Compare with the solution

Since h² = I, B2=(I+h)2=2(I+h)=2BB^2=(I+h)^2=2(I+h)=2B, and B3=4BB^3=4B. The dimension is dB = 2. It is explicitly reducible and does not have a simple group inverse. A normalized represented operator (I + Uh)/2 can be a projector, but that normalization does not erase the integer fusion multiplicities or make the defect simple.

Take it with you

  • Topological deformation and fusion require a declared defect and junction setting.
  • Direct-sum multiplicities count channels and cannot be read as probabilities.
  • Fusion rings and quantum dimensions are useful but omit associator, boundary, and operator-action data.

Read further

Original sources and deeper explanations to follow at your own pace.

Optional progress, saved in this browser when available. Revisit any lesson at any time.

Lesson not marked complete.