Curvature traces obey identities without containing every tidal component
Contract the Riemann tensor, derive the divergence-free Einstein tensor, and distinguish local identities from global flux statements.
On this page
The question for today
What you’ll understand
- Compute Ricci and scalar contractions with the stated curvature convention.
- Use the contracted Bianchi identity to identify a divergence-free tensor.
- Distinguish Ricci-flat geometry from fully flat geometry and handle volume boundaries.
The Riemann tensor contains more information than many gravitational equations need directly. Its Ricci contraction and scalar trace organize local volume focusing and enter Einstein’s equation, while a differential identity constrains their divergence. Tracing loses information, however: a four-dimensional vacuum region can have nonzero tidal curvature even when its Ricci tensor vanishes. We will compute a sphere example and explain how local covariant identities connect to integration only after the measure and boundary terms are specified.
Contractions keep some curvature and discard other parts
Use Rμν=Rρμρν with the Riemann convention already declared. Metric compatibility and the Levi-Civita curvature symmetries make this Ricci tensor symmetric. A further contraction with the inverse metric gives the Ricci scalar. The inverse matters: in angular coordinates its entries supply inverse length squared, so a dimensionless angular Ricci component can still contribute to a scalar in m⁻². The Einstein tensor subtracts one half the scalar times the metric. These are tensor constructions, not operations tied to one special coordinate chart.
On a round two-sphere, Rθθ=1 and Rφφ=sin²θ. Contracting with the inverse radius-squared metric gives R=2/a². In two dimensions the Einstein tensor vanishes identically despite this nonzero curvature; a four-dimensional interpretation must not be imported into that dimensional identity. In four dimensions, the Weyl part retains curvature not specified by Ricci traces. Schwarzschild vacuum has Rμν=0 but a nonzero Riemann-square invariant 48m²/r⁶, where m=GM/c² is a length. Thus even a vanishing Ricci scalar is far from a proof of flatness.
The Bianchi identity is geometric rather than a field equation
The differential Bianchi identity is a cyclic relation among covariant derivatives of Riemann curvature. Contract it twice and use metric compatibility to obtain ∇μRμν equal to one half the gradient of R. The Einstein tensor therefore has zero covariant divergence for every sufficiently smooth metric with its Levi-Civita connection. No matter equation or Einstein equation was required. When the gravitational field equation relates this tensor to matter stress, the identity provides a consistency condition with covariant matter conservation.
Covariant conservation does not automatically provide a globally conserved ordinary energy in an arbitrary spacetime. The extra free tensor index means one cannot integrate components at different points as though their bases were the same. Symmetry, boundary conditions, and suitable currents are needed for a global charge. A cosmological term Λgμν has vanishing divergence when Λ is constant. Treating Λ as an arbitrary position-dependent scalar while keeping an otherwise unchanged conserved source would violate the same local consistency condition unless additional dynamical contributions are included.
A volume identity requires a directed boundary flux
For a vector current the covariant divergence is the coordinate derivative of √|g| times the current, divided by √|g|. Integrating with the invariant density converts it to a directed boundary flux by Stokes’ theorem. Orientation fixes the signs of initial and final pieces, and induced measures must be used. A non-null boundary can be expressed using a normalized normal with the appropriate Lorentzian orientation sign. A null boundary needs a separate surface-element construction because its normal is also tangent; setting a unit normal there is invalid. Boundary terms vanish only under stated boundary conditions.
The function lab illustrates the sphere scalar’s inverse-radius scaling. Reset and set both controls to a=2,x=0.5, predicting y=0.5. Reset and set a=2,x=1, predicting y=2. Assign x to an inverse radius in chosen reference-length units and y to the corresponding dimensionless scalar 2x². Halving radius quadruples this curvature. The lab computes neither tensor traces nor a boundary flux; the interpretation depends on the analytic sphere metric, not on the parabola alone.
Work it through
Trace the curvature of a two-sphere
A round sphere has radius a=2 m. At its equator the metric is diag(4,4) m² and Ricci components are diag(1,1). Find R and the two Einstein-tensor components, and explain why their values do not imply flatness.
The inverse metric at the equator is diag(1/4,1/4) m⁻². The scalar is R=(1/4)×1+(1/4)×1=0.50 m⁻².
Each Einstein component is 1−(1/2)×0.50×4=0. The vanishing occurs because of the two-dimensional trace identity.
The sphere still has sectional curvature 1/a²=0.25 m⁻² and nonzero Riemann curvature. The two-dimensional Einstein tensor has lost that information through its special identity.
The scalar is R=0.50 m⁻² and both diagonal Einstein components vanish, while the sphere remains intrinsically curved.
The living notebook
Explore the model
Interactive lab · function
Test curvature versus inverse radius
Reset and set BOTH controls to a=2,x=0.5, predicting y=0.5. Reset and set a=2,x=1, predicting y=2. Assign x to normalized inverse sphere radius and y=2x². This is scalar scaling only, with no Ricci contraction or Bianchi solver.
- y at chosen x
- 0.608
- Tangent slope · 2ax
- 1.35
- Signed area · ax³/3
- 0.182
This lab uses only y = ax². Playback traces the curve within the fixed integration interval from 0 to x; it does not estimate numerical error or change the chosen point. Parameter changes pause playback and recompute the model at the current elapsed time. Reset restores both parameters and returns time to zero. Playback starts paused. Adjust either parameter, then choose Play or Step.
Look forSphere curvature scales as inverse radius squared; a vanishing traced combination need not mean full curvature vanishes.
Pause & reason
Check your understanding
Your turn
Try it yourself
In a four-dimensional Einstein space let Rμν=Λgμν with constant Λ=0.020 m⁻². Find R, Gμν, and G₀₀ in an orthonormal −+++ frame. Verify the vacuum equation Gμν+Λgμν=0.
Take a moment to make a prediction or work it out on paper. Open a hint when you need one.
Give me a hint
The mixed trace gμνgμν is the dimension four. The orthonormal time-time metric entry is −1.
Compare with the solution
R=4Λ=0.080 m⁻². Then Gμν=Λgμν−(1/2)(4Λ)gμν=−Λgμν. In the orthonormal frame G₀₀=+0.020 m⁻². Adding Λgμν cancels every component. Constancy of Λ also makes its covariant divergence vanish by metric compatibility.
Keep the idea
Take it with you
- Ricci contractions discard curvature information that can remain in Weyl tides.
- The contracted Bianchi identity holds geometrically before a field equation is imposed.
- Global flux claims require invariant measures, orientation and boundary conditions.
Read further
Original sources and deeper explanations to follow at your own pace.
Optional progress, saved in this browser when available. Revisit any lesson at any time.
Lesson not marked complete.