research31 min studyLesson 721 in Physics

Spinor-helicity variables for massless momenta

Factor null momentum matrices into spinors with explicit metric, bracket, energy-sign, and crossing conventions.

On this page

What you’ll understand

  • Reconstruct a null four-momentum from two spinors.
  • Calculate an invariant from oriented antisymmetric brackets.
  • Distinguish real positive-energy spinors from their analytic continuations and crossing phases.

A massless four-momentum can be represented by a rank-one two-by-two matrix. Factoring that matrix replaces its null constraint with two unconstrained spinors and a scaling redundancy. This is particularly useful because amplitudes naturally depend on helicity and complex phases that squared momentum invariants hide. The representation is precise only after declaring the metric, bracket signs, and momentum-flow convention. A spinor component is not a directly measured particle probability amplitude by itself.

A null matrix has a rank-one factorization

Use natural units with hbar and c equal to one and metric signature plus minus minus minus. Throughout this module every external momentum flows inward, and their sum vanishes. Physical final-state momenta therefore enter with reversed sign. Form the momentum matrix with energy plus longitudinal momentum in its upper-left entry. Its determinant equals the Minkowski norm, so a nonzero null momentum has rank one and admits an undotted-column times dotted-row factorization.

Each spinor has units of the square root of energy. For a real future-directed momentum one may choose the dotted spinor as the complex conjugate of the undotted spinor. A negative-energy real momentum instead needs a relative sign, and general complex momenta do not obey a conjugation relation. Enforcing positive-energy conjugation during a complex deformation would incorrectly restrict the analytic variables on which recursion relies.

pαα˙=(p0+p3p1−ip2p1+ip2p0−p3)=λαλ~α˙,det⁡p=pμpμ=0,∑ipiμ=0p_{\alpha\dot\alpha}=\begin{pmatrix}p^0+p^3&p^1-ip^2\\p^1+ip^2&p^0-p^3\end{pmatrix}=\lambda_\alpha\widetilde\lambda_{\dot\alpha},\qquad \det p=p_\mu p^\mu=0,\qquad \sum_i p_i^\mu=0
The factorization applies to nonzero massless momentum in signature (+,−,−,−). p has energy units and each spinor square-root-energy units. All arrows are incoming, including the sign-reversed physical final momenta; the displayed matrix fixes the component convention.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

Antisymmetric brackets remember orientation

Define an angle bracket as the determinant of the two undotted columns. Define the square bracket with the reverse determinant order for the dotted columns. Both are antisymmetric, and the product of an angle bracket with the oppositely ordered square bracket equals twice the momentum dot product. Stating the component definitions is safer than importing a remembered conjugation rule from a source using different index positions or metric signs.

For the future-directed real choice just described, the oppositely ordered square bracket is the complex conjugate of the angle bracket. Their product is consequently nonnegative for two such null momenta. With crossed energy signs or complex kinematics that positivity inference no longer applies. The invariant still follows algebraically from the determinant identity, even when neither bracket is the complex conjugate of the other and the invariant itself is complex.

⟨ij⟩=λi1λj2−λi2λj1,[ij]=λ~i2λ~j1−λ~i1λ~j2,sij=2pi⋅pj=⟨ij⟩[ji]\langle ij\rangle=\lambda_{i1}\lambda_{j2}-\lambda_{i2}\lambda_{j1},\qquad [ij]=\widetilde\lambda_{i2}\widetilde\lambda_{j1}-\widetilde\lambda_{i1}\widetilde\lambda_{j2},\qquad s_{ij}=2p_i\cdot p_j=\langle ij\rangle[ji]
Brackets have energy units and sij energy-squared units. The reversed dotted determinant is deliberate. For real future-directed legs with tildeλ=λ*, [ji]=⟨ij⟩* in this component convention; it is not a constraint on complex kinematics.↔ Scroll wide equations horizontally.

Redundancy and crossing require different operations

Multiplying one undotted spinor by a nonzero number and dividing its dotted partner by the same number leaves momentum unchanged. This is the spinor version of the massless little-group freedom. Real positive-energy conjugation restricts that transformation to a phase, while complexified kinematics permits a general nonzero complex scale. Helicity amplitudes transform with definite weights under this freedom rather than being scalar functions of the momentum matrices alone.

Crossing reverses momentum, so it requires a different operation. One convenient analytic prescription multiplies both spinors by i, producing minus the original matrix. It also introduces phases into every bracket involving that leg. Reinterpreting a physical particle between initial and final states requires the corresponding antiparticle and helicity assignment; momentum replacement alone is insufficient. These conventions organize amplitudes before squaring, so convention phases cancel only when all interfering contributions use the same external-state choices.

Two opposite null directions

Consider a pair of future-directed momenta, not an entire momentum-conserving process: p1=(2,0,0,2) GeV and p2=(2,0,0,−2) GeV. Choose λ1=tildeλ1=(2,0) and λ2=tildeλ2=(0,2) in square-root-GeV units. Find their matrices, ⟨12⟩, [21], and s12.

  1. The outer products give diagonal matrices diag(4,0) and diag(0,4) GeV, respectively. Both determinants vanish, and reading back their entries gives the stated energies and opposite longitudinal momenta.

  2. The angle determinant is 4 GeV. With the declared reversed dotted determinant, the oppositely ordered bracket [21] is also 4 GeV. Using [12] instead would insert an erroneous minus sign.

  3. The product gives s12=16 GeV2s_{12}=16\,\mathrm{GeV^2}. Directly, p1+p2=(4,0,0,0) GeV has squared norm 16 GeV², independently checking the normalization and sign.

The result

Both momenta are null, the two required brackets are +4 GeV, and their pair invariant is +16 GeV². These two inward momenta alone do not satisfy a complete process's momentum conservation.

Explore the model

Interactive lab

Interactive lab · vectors

One complex component's phase

Represent a single complex spinor component as a planar vector. Reset and set both controls to Angle 0° and Magnitude 2; predict components (2,0). For a fresh comparison, Reset and set both controls to Angle 90° and Magnitude 2; predict (0,2), corresponding to multiplication by i. This illustrates one component's crossing phase only.

One complex component's phasePlayback traces a fixed vector and its projections. Angle and magnitude set the geometry; the moving marker does not change them. Current readings: x component: 1.393; y component: 0.975; Magnitude: 1.7. All parameters are adjustable with the labeled controls below.−7.46−3.7303.737.46−3.5−1.7501.753.5xyvvₓ = 1.39
Vectorx / y projectionsTrace marker
x component
1.393
y component
0.975
Magnitude
1.7
t = 0 s

Playback traces a fixed vector and its projections. Angle and magnitude set the geometry; the moving marker does not change them. Parameter changes pause playback and recompute the model at the current elapsed time. Reset restores both parameters and returns time to zero. Playback starts paused. Adjust either parameter, then choose Play or Step.

Look forThe planar vector contains neither a full pair of Weyl spinors nor a Lorentz momentum matrix. Reconstructing momentum requires the analytic outer product; its displayed vector components are not scattering probabilities.

Check your understanding

For complexified null momenta, which condition must be retained?

Try it yourself

Cross only leg 1 of the worked pair using λ1→iλ1 and tildeλ1→i tildeλ1. Find its new momentum, the transformed brackets ⟨12⟩ and [21], and the new invariant. Does tildeλ1=λ1* still hold?

Take a moment to make a prediction or work it out on paper. Open a hint when you need one.

Give me a hint

The outer product gains i², while a bracket involving the leg once gains i. Compare the two transformed spinors under conjugation.

Compare with the solution

The momentum becomes −p1. Both listed brackets become 4i GeV, so their product is −16 GeV², agreeing with twice (−p1)·p2. The new dotted spinor equals minus the conjugate of the new undotted spinor, as required for this negative-energy real matrix. Crossing has changed momentum; it is not the momentum-preserving little-group transformation with reciprocal scaling.

Take it with you

  • Null momentum matrices factor into two spinors with a scaling redundancy.
  • Component bracket definitions fix signs of invariant products and conjugation rules.
  • Crossing and complex continuation require controlled external-state phases and energy-sign bookkeeping.

Read further

Original sources and deeper explanations to follow at your own pace.

Optional progress, saved in this browser when available. Revisit any lesson at any time.

Lesson not marked complete.