Fractional charge and anyonic statistics
Separate fractional quasihole charge, exchange and full-winding phases, and non-Abelian fusion structure from ordinary path-dependent phases.
On this page
The question for today
What you’ll understand
- Compute Laughlin quasihole charge and distinguish exchange from a full braid.
- Track Abelian fusion labels modulo local particles.
- Separate statistical, Aharonov–Bohm and dynamical phase contributions in an interference experiment.
A fractional Hall quasihole is a collective excitation of an interacting electron liquid. Its fractional charge does not mean that an isolated fundamental electron has been cut into constituent particles in vacuum. Transporting such excitations around one another can also change a many-body amplitude by a fractional statistical phase. Charge, exchange statistics, and fusion are related properties of the phase, but they describe different experiments and must not be replaced by one unspecified geometric phase.
A missing fraction of local density carries a definite charge
For a Laughlin state at filling one over m, inserting the appropriate flux creates a quasihole with charge positive e divided by m relative to the electron liquid. Its density deficit is spread over a microscopic correlation scale rather than attached to a smaller fundamental electron. A localized quasihole wavefunction can be constructed by multiplying by one factor connecting each electron coordinate to the quasihole position. Charge determination requires the liquid's screening and adiabatic-response assumptions, not merely counting a polynomial zero.
Several quasiholes combine into Abelian sectors labelled by their number modulo m after quotienting by local electron excitations. The charge of a sector is correspondingly specified modulo an integer electron charge, with any attached local particle recorded separately. Such sector labels are nonlocal properties of a gapped phase. They cannot be distinguished by arbitrary local rearrangements far from the excitation, but a physical detector still sees ordinary nonnegative probabilities.
One exchange is not a full winding
For elementary identical Laughlin quasiholes, a chosen oriented exchange contributes pi over m, whereas moving one all the way around another contributes twice that angle. Confusing these two paths produces a factor-of-two error. Reversing an oriented braid reverses its Abelian statistical phase. The overall phase is only defined modulo two pi, and comparing it experimentally requires interfering suitable histories rather than reading an absolute phase of one isolated ket.
A moving charged quasihole also accumulates an Aharonov–Bohm phase from enclosed magnetic flux, and energy integrated over the path produces a dynamical phase. Changing a path's area or duration can therefore change its total phase even without changing the braid's topology. Extracting statistics requires a protocol that controls, cancels, or calibrates those additional terms. A total phase equal to zero modulo two pi does not by itself establish bosonic exchange.
Non-Abelian braiding acts on a fusion space
Abelian sectors fuse into a unique sector for a specified pair of labels, so well separated braids act by phases. Non-Abelian anyons can have more than one allowed fusion channel. Several excitations with fixed total charge then support a state space on which braids act by matrices. Different braid sequences can fail to commute even after common dynamical phases are removed. This is stronger structure than assigning one exotic exchange angle to every trajectory.
For example, the Ising fusion rule sigma times sigma allows either the vacuum or a fermion channel. A measurement of that channel is different from simply counting the number of excitations. Reliable topological manipulation also requires a gap, large separation compared with correlation length, slow motion relative to bulk excitations, and control of residual splitting and poisoning. Fractional statistics is established phase structure; claims of complete protection or a particular experimental realization need separate evidence and error assumptions.
Work it through
A statistical phase hidden in a full phase budget
For an m=3 Laughlin liquid choose the positive braid convention above. One elementary quasihole winds once around another. A reference calibration gives an additional Aharonov–Bohm contribution +4π/3 and cancels dynamical phases. Find quasihole charge, statistical phase, and total relative phase.
Each elementary quasihole has charge +e/3. Its exchange angle in the chosen orientation is π/3, but the specified path is a full winding rather than one exchange.
The winding statistical phase is therefore . This value depends on the enclosed topological excitation and is separate from the already calibrated electromagnetic phase contribution.
Add the phase budget: , equivalent to zero modulo 2π. The vanishing total interference offset does not erase the nontrivial exchange angle.
The charge is +e/3, the full-winding statistical phase is +2π/3, and the calibrated total phase is zero modulo 2π. Identifying statistics from the total alone would give a false conclusion.
The living notebook
Explore the model
Interactive lab · waves
A phase can change an interference amplitude
Reset and set both controls to Phase difference 0° and Amplitude ratio 1; predict resultant amplitude 2. For a fresh comparison representing a 2π/3 relative phase, Reset and set both controls to Phase difference 120° and Amplitude ratio 1; predict resultant amplitude 1. These are equal-frequency mathematical waves illustrating phase-sensitive addition, not quasihole paths.
- Sum at x = 0
- 0.866
- Resultant amplitude
- 1.732
- Phase difference
- 60°
Two waves share the same frequency and wave number. Playback advances t in sin(2x − t) + a sin(2x − t + phase). Parameter changes pause playback and recompute the model at the current elapsed time. Reset restores both parameters and returns time to zero. Playback starts paused. Adjust either parameter, then choose Play or Step.
Look forA relative phase affects coherent interference. The wave lab contains no anyons, enclosed magnetic flux, fusion channels, or statistical-phase extraction and has no adjustable dispersion.
Pause & reason
Check your understanding
Your turn
Try it yourself
In an m=5 Laughlin liquid, a composite of two elementary quasiholes winds positively around one elementary quasihole. Find the composite's charge, the mutual winding phase, and the fusion sector after combining all three.
Take a moment to make a prediction or work it out on paper. Open a hint when you need one.
Give me a hint
Use sector labels a=2 and b=1. Mutual winding uses their product, while fusion uses their sum modulo five.
Compare with the solution
The moving composite has charge +2e/5, up to any separately attached local electron charge. The mutual phase is . Fusion gives sector 3 modulo five, with representative quasihole charge +3e/5. The charge sum and phase product are different operations. These Abelian rules give a unique sector; they do not produce a multidimensional non-Abelian fusion space.
Keep the idea
Take it with you
- Laughlin quasihole charge is fractional relative to the correlated liquid.
- One exchange and a full winding differ by a factor of two in their elementary Abelian statistical phase.
- Statistical braids must be separated from dynamical and electromagnetic phases, while non-Abelian braids require a fusion-space description.
Read further
Original sources and deeper explanations to follow at your own pace.
Optional progress, saved in this browser when available. Revisit any lesson at any time.
Lesson not marked complete.